Located in the lower level of the Methaqua Lodge, the main indoor facility of Wesley Woods, Otterbein has 4 rooms, 3 rooms have 4 beds each and the fourth has 8 beds. Each room has a sink and mirror. There are shared restrooms with shower facilities as well as a lounge with wood fireplace and kitchenette. Otterbein Inn can accommodate up to 20 people.

The inn is located on the main campus within easy walking of both dining halls, the chapel, Activity Center, ropes courses, pool, archery, Lake Ahquabi, a basketball court, and sand volleyball court. Otterbein Inn is heated and air conditioned.